What am I going to listen to?

What am I going to listen to?

Guest Author: Matt McInerney

Hello, my name is Matt McInerney and I have a confession to make: I have more music than I know what to do with in my iTunes Library. My glass is not half full. It is completely full and spilling over the rim. Yes, I’m approaching 10,000 songs… Here’s the thing though: I’d have it no other way! I don’t think I could deal if one of my albums were missing. Even if one song were misplaced, I have to admit I’d be upset. So where am I going with this? I’ll tell you: with a song count in the thousands, how am I ever suppose to decided what to listen to? One’s first instinct may be to create playlists. Sure that will work for the a little bit, but that also is going to have some major flaws. First, in selecting certain songs, there are far too many being overlooked. Second, who has the time to make enough playlists to support every mood and time of day? With this in mind, I’d like to cover the all the bases of iTunes organization and potential. Let’s figure this one out.

Random
Alright, there’s a thoughts. Start from the top of your library, turn on shuffle, and just hit go. It may work for a little bit, but for anyone with differing tastes or a library populated not only with music but audiobooks and podcasts as well, you’ll find yourself spending more time skipping to next track than is worth. And if you’re trying to get work done with music in the background, you’ll never get anything done!

Party Shuffle
Okay,maybe iTunes can deal with your problem. They’ve got Party Shuffle right? Then you can bring ratings into the equation, and select your source. This used to be sufficient as my song count first peaked a thousand, but as the number rose, so did the time spent skipping to the next song.

Smart Playlists
For the longest time, Smart Playlists were my savior. I have to say, for the most part, they still are. If you’re unfamiliar, Smart Playlist will let you set rules about your library to create live updating playlists. So let’s say you want to have one playlist with your most recently played songs, one with your top rated songs, and one with your recent addition to the library. A smart playlist can handle each of these needs in just a few clicks, and will always stay up to date. Not to mention that you could make playlist that would take a random sampling of those three playlists, and shuffle through them. So far, I think this is the way to go when it comes to finding what you want to listen to.

Beats per Minute?
Potion Factory not too long ago came out with an application called Tangerine. The idea behind Tangerine was that it would go through you library, and sort it by beats per minutes, so that you could separate out your slow-tempo mellow songs from your upbeat fast paced ones. The problem is that it just doesn’t work too well. You’ll quickly realize that the BPMs do not really define mood too well. If only there were a way to tag by mood…

Mood Tagging
Oh wait, there is! This is a recent discovery of mine, called Moody. Moody gives one a colorful square scale. The vertical ranges from Calm to Intense, while the horizontal ranges from Sad to Happy. Think of those political tests you took in high school to determine whether you were a communist, a fascist, a libertarian, or a moderate… Similar scale, just for mood. I have to say, after some time spent with it, i love this idea. It will take some time spent tagging my songs, but the beautify is, once they’re tagged, the ease of generating playlists is amazing. While there are times that I hesitate to find a spot on the scale for a song, retagging at a later date is simple enough.

Conclusion
As it stands right now, I love the thought of tagging songs by mood. It’s what I’ve spent a long time trying to do with Smart Playlists. However, at the end of the day, I don’t think I’ll ever stray too far from Smart Playlists. A good mix up of recently played, new, and top rated songs is pretty hard to beat.



  • Guest
    If you people have that many songs, thousands, you need to get a life outside of downloading music. 50,000 mp3s? You know there are real things to do, sailing, swimming, hiking, traveling. There is a real world, try getting outside and enjoying reality.

    I'm speaking as a former professional musician, so I am not a music-hater at all. I have a large and varied collection myself, but 10,000+? Sheesh!
  • You might also check out The Filter. It's an app that creates playlists based on something similar to he music genome project (what Pandora uses). You can randomly create playlists or select a song or two and create a playlist based off of those two songs. Seems to work pretty well.
  • Check out MoodShuffle from http://www.moodshuffle.com

    It figures out your current mood each time you run it. Skip or listen to the first few songs, and it locks on to your mood. No need to create playlists. What is really cool is it seems to lock in on stuff you wouldn't think of grouping together. Like I noticed it was playing my new music one time. Older stuff the next. It has a simple interface, but seems to be doing a lot behind the scenes.
  • I was wrong. Its around 80,000 songs :)

    http://me.dnszones.org:8888/
  • Daniel K
    The ideal plugin/fix for me, would be to have some sort of hook-up with Pandora and their indexing working on your machine, and then have it suggest other songs from your own library. So it would be something like "Oh, your listening to 'this' and 'this' type of song, so maybe listen to this song next, 'cause it match with 'this' and 'this'" - Something like that... and have it work with both specific albums, artists and individual songs, ideally. Hopefully, it would save you from having to tag and sort all your songs manually, and be more detailed at the same time.

    Oh, and 10.000 and 50.000 songs? woah... I've only got half my cd's on here (plus all the stuff from iTunes and eMusic), and I'm only at 2500 I think.
  • @Nick I have a Macbook Pro with 100gb, and I really need to buy a hard drive just dedicated to music
    @Phil I think Apple should think about buying Moody the way they bought Coverflow... It would be a great feature for iTunes 8.0
  • I have also recently discovered Moody and have been taggin my library as I listen and in short bursts. It works really well, although it is a bit tough deciding the levels on some songs. I imagine once most of my library is tagged I will find my self using it a lot, I only wish it integrated with iTunes a little more rather than sitting on the side of it.
  • Jeez! 10,000 songs? Hope you have a huge hard drive :-p
  • Matt;

    Good post. I'm in a similar situation. I have almost 50,000 mp3's, and Random or Party shuffle are very rarely used anymore. Most of my lisening is with a conventional search by song/artist, listing to new podcasts, or I typically use smart playlists myself.

    Mood tagging sounds cool, but man - it is going to take me months to tag everything.

    Good article!
blog comments powered by Disqus